In late August, Medicare issued a
final local coverage determination (LCD) for power mobility devices (PMDs). The
new coverage policy had serious access implications for beneficiaries with
mobility disabilities. The
new LCD implements a series of new payment codes for power wheelchairs and
scooters, providing Medicare coverage for those devices with functional
capabilities that place them into either Groups 1 (lowest
functioning), 2, or 3 (highest functioning) PMDs.
Essentially, the new policy had
three major problems. First, the policy would significantly
"downcode" the Medicare wheelchair benefit placing many individuals
into inadequate and often unsafe power wheelchairs. Second, the new policy
requires that a beneficiary be unable to "stand and pivot" in order
to qualify for the highest functioning chair - a standard that fails to take
into account the functional needs of an individual. And third, the policy
implements a new definition of the "in the home" restriction by
denying access to wheelchairs that have capabilities which are deemed
unnecessary for indoor use.
Many ITEM Coalition members
expressed serious concern with the new policy, calling for a rescission of the
entire policy, an end to the downcoding, and the adoption of more
functional-based coverage standards. On September 20, 2006, CMS
released “clarifications” to the LCD that address some of the problems
identified by stakeholders while leaving several harmful provisions in place.
The LCD clarifications will alleviate some of the access concerns associated
with downcoding from Group 2 to Group 1 wheelchairs. This downcoding
was of great concern because many individuals with disabilities would have
been placed in inadequate and often unsafe mobility devices. Additionally,
the clarifications delay the implementation date of the LCD from October
1, 2006 to November 15, 2006. This delay allows clinicians and providers
additional time to become familiar with the coverage changes and analyze
the impact. CMS deserves credit fro these revisions.
The “stand and pivot” standard, however, remains a major problem. The
LCD states that in order to qualify for a Group 3 device, the beneficiary
must be “unable to independently stand and pivot to transfer due to a neurological
condition or myopathy.” However, there are many individuals with
disabilities who may be able to stand and pivot but will need a Group 3
device to participate in their daily activities.
Finally, the clarifications do nothing to fix the new and more restrictive
interpretation of the “in the home” rule. The LCD states that PMDs with
capabilities not needed for use in the home (identified as Group 4 devices)
will be downcoded to a Group 3 device. Medicare currently covers
wheelchairs that are needed by individuals for use in their homes but has
not prevented individuals from using the devices outside of their homes.
However, this new policy will not cover devices that have features that
are useful for out-of-home use.
We urge you to contact Members of
Congress asking them to support legislation to eliminate Medicare’s “in the
home” restriction for mobility devices (S. 3677/H.R. 5983). Without enactment of “in the home” legislation,
Medicare will continue to utilize this discriminatory coverage restriction to
prevent access to appropriate mobility devices for people with
disabilities. You can contact your Members of Congress via the Capitol
switchboard toll-free at 1-877-224-0041 or via email at http://ga3.org/campaign/CommunityAccess.
The LCD and clarifications can be
found at http://www.trustsolutionsllc.com/DRAFT_LCD_Status.asp.